X17 Reports that this is Ashley, not Mary-Kate at first and then edited b/c of the scathing comments left by viewers who knew this is DEF MK!

Then the reported goes on to say:
"Despite being a pretty avid Olsen twins fan, there are just some instances where its hard for us to tell them apart. Take these pics, for example, which sparked a pretty big debate in the office and several minutes of Googling before we eventually came to the conclusion that its Mary-Kate not Ashley"

"1) The lips. Ashleys upper lip is fuller than Mary-Kate's
2) THe Thighs. Sorry, Ash, but again, your are usually fuller than Mary-Kates!"

When i first saw this yesterday before they edited it and actually did their research, they were sure that it was Ashley and not Mary-Kate. I can tell them apart very easily, dont know if anyone else can, but dont you feel bad for MK. She's obviously trying to get healthier than she was in the past and I doubt stupid stuff like this makes it any easier....

Idk for me I can always tell them apart....I actually saw this on x17 yesterday and knew they were wrong when they reported her as Ash. It's obviously MK!

i personally think that you can always tell them apart

i can tell them apart... i watched their movies when i was little and could always tell them apart...
too me they look different..

BTW. MK'S OUTIFT IS AMAZING!!!!

i can alwaysss tell them apart! they do though look so much more alike that different, but still you should be able to tell them apart easily.
ps i love her outfit

maybe because mk tied up her hair. it does look a little like ash. but the outfit looks so mk, too mk. and it resembles anoutfit she wore a few days ago. haha. its a nice outfit. i like that bag. can anyone id it?

I dont know, I would like to know as well. I read on WWWD that Alexander Wang had a ton of messanger bags this season. Maybe its his??? Idk

I think the hole confuion comes from the hair up.. that's Ash's signature look, and the fact that MK has gained a bit of weight, esp. on the leg area. But as someone else said, that outft is totaly MK!